Book Review
Altering Historical Circumstances
- Michael Barnholden (Author)
Circumstances Alter Photographs: Captain James Peters' Reports from the War of 1885. Talonbooks (purchase at Amazon.ca)
Reviewed by June Scudeler
As a Métis person, the prospect of reviewing Circumstances Alter Photographs: Captain James Peters’ Reports from the War of 1885 (or as Métis call it, the 1885 Resistance) did cause a bit of apprehension. Peters, born in Saint John, New Brunswick in 1853, was a captain in the Royal Canadian Artillery’s “A” Battery. Peters took the world’s first battlefield photos at the Métis victory at Tourond’s Coulee (Fish Creek), where one of my ancestors was killed and another wounded, as well as photographs at Batoche.
However, Michael Barnholden, who translated Gabriel Dumont Speaks, a series of interviews with the Métis buffalo hunter and leader of the Métis forces, tellingly entitled this book, Circumstances Alter Photographs, a reference to Peters’ admission that the photographer may not possess the ability to choose his subject or the “narrative framing of the subject.” Peters was fortunate to have the 1883 “detective” camera, which could be carried over the shoulder, along with a dozen prepared glass plates, enabling Peters to take photos during battle. While there are photographs of the American Civil War and the Crimean War, these were taken after the battle, making Peters’ photos the first photos ever taken during battle. Not all of Peters’ photographs are of battlefields; “Métis Women” shows four women carrying some of their possessions to a refugee camp piled with Métis belongings. Peters also took photographs of Poundmaker, Beardy and Miserable Man. In keeping with Western tradition, Miserable Man’s wife is nameless as she is referred to as “Mrs Miserable Man.”
Barnholden provides extensive historical and critical commentary on Peters as well as Peters’ dispatches from the front printed in newspapers. The surprise in Captain James Peters’ Reports from the War of 1885 is Peters himself. Barnholden describes him as critical of the Canadian military; Peters referred to General Middleton, leader of the Canadian forces, as “the d____d old fool of a General” and expressed some sympathy for the Métis and First Nations fighting in 1885. He sardonically referred to a photo of Canadian officers at Batoche as “Big Guns.” Peters also notes with some sympathy, “One old brave said that it would be cheaper for the Queen to give him pork than pay for all these soldiers. This was not a bad hit.” This sympathy only comes after battle; previously Peters describes the Métis as “murderous brutes” who have ruthlessly slaughtered priests and settlers.
While Barnholden does a good job with the critical apparatus in the book (although a map of Peters’ journey with the “A” Battery would have been a welcome addition), I am wary of the lack of Métis voices. While those interested could read Gabriel Dumont Speaks separately, excerpts from the book would provide a counterpoint to the Canadian version of events.
Similar reviews
- Imagining Justice by Kristina Fagan
Books reviewed: Citizens Plus: Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian State by Alan C. Cairns and Justice in Paradise by Bruce Clark - Utopies d'une Amérique française by Constance Cartmill
Books reviewed: Utopies en Canada (1545-1845) by Bernard J. Andrès and Nancy Desjardins and La Nouvelle-France. Les Français en Amérique du Nord XVIe-XVIIIe siècle by Jacques Mathieu - Of Selves and Others by Carole Turner
Books reviewed: Wild Mouse by Chris Chambers and Derek McCormack, Somewhere Running by Nathalie Stephens, Hypothesis by John Barton, and ashes are bone and dust by Jill Battson - The Need for Stories by Renate Eigenbrod
Books reviewed: Suddenly They Heard Footsteps: Storytelling for the Twenty-First Century by Dan Yashinsky and Our Story: Aboriginal Voices On Canada's Past by Tantoo Cardinal, Tomson Highway, and Lee Maracle - Altering Historical Circumstances by June Scudeler
Books reviewed: Circumstances Alter Photographs: Captain James Peters' Reports from the War of 1885 by Michael Barnholden
MLA: Scudeler, June. Altering Historical Circumstances. canlit.ca. Canadian Literature, 8 Dec. 2011. Web. 22 May 2013.
This review originally appeared in Canadian Literature #208 (Spring 2011), Prison Writing. (pg. 128 - 129)
***Please note that the articles and reviews from the Canadian Literature website (www.canlit.ca) may not be the final versions as they are printed in the journal, as additional editing sometimes takes place between the two versions. If you are quoting from the website, please indicate the date accessed when citing the web version of reviews and articles.
