Book Review
Death and Transcendence
- Dean Serravalle (Author)
Reliving Charlie. Oberon Press (purchase at Amazon.ca)
- Mark Sedore (Author)
Snowmen. 3-Day Books (purchase at Amazon.ca - Tom Managhan (Author)
The Bottle Collector. Your Scrivener Press (purchase at Amazon.ca
Reviewed by Justin Shaw
The male protagonists in these novels are concerned with transcending death—literally and figuratively. All three men take journeys to reflect upon their past and to challenge themselves to affirm their existence, with varying, though sometimes predictable results.
Dean Serravalle, in his debut novel Reliving Charley, delivers a cautionary tale on a recurrent theme in Western narrative: mortality and the desire to transcend it. Serravalle’s economical prose articulates the heavy existential subject matter with clarity and ease, avoiding pontifications on the plight of humanity. Rather than focusing on the tragic process of individuation characterizing the Romantic confrontation with death, Serravalle instead examines how death can be a catalyst for raising a greater social awareness. The novel opens with the titular character mourning his wife’s recent death. Charley’s friend Samuel then reveals that he has developed a stem-cell serum that regenerates cellular growth and reverses aging. However, this Faustian tale eventually undermines Charley and Samuel’s attempts at death-transcendence, suggesting that their desire for immortality is the same selfish impulse evident in the acquisitive lifestyle of the youth-oriented American Dream.
Serravalle explores the gendered aspect of the American ethos of acquisition, as both men attempt to use their invigorating
youth to (re)acquire the love of Linda, a common love interest. Aligning this masculinist orientation with the ethos of capitalistic acquisition underlying the American Dream, Samuel begins to envision Jay Gatsby as his personal mentor in hallucinations—a side effect of the serum. In this sense, the reverse-aging serum is more than a simple means to transcend physical death; it also gives Charley and Samuel a second chance to live out [the] imaginings
they suppressed in the past, including excesses such as infidelity. But the serum has an unanticipated feature: stressful situations, such as those brought on by the acquisitive lifestyle, drastically increase the rate of regression, bringing them closer to birth/death. Samuel, whose acquisitive orientation is stronger than Charley’s, eventually succumbs to this reverse fate, while Charley learns to temper his selfish inclinations to prolong his youth indefinitely, which secures his relationship with Linda. Thus, Serravalle suggests that dreams of immortality must always be approached with caution: there is always risk in liv[ing] out our imaginings.
Mark Sedore’s debut novel Snowmen was the winner of the thirty-second 3-day Novel Contest. Sedore also tackles mortality and its attendant existential concerns, though he does so with a detached irony that is both his strength and weakness. Snowmen depicts the cold relations between brothers Charlie and Larry, the latter of whom has Asperger’s, which only exacerbates the situation. When Larry is diagnosed with cancer, he decides to raise money for cancer research by being the first person to walk solo across the Arctic Circle. But when his sickness prevents him from doing so, Charlie decides to do the walk for him.
With its alternating narrative structure, between Arctic present and past backstory, Sedore’s novel shifts from survivalist fiction to family drama/romance. His spare prose captures the sublime Arctic landscape,while also articulating the quotidian idiosyncrasies of Charlie’s experience. In the most notable instance of the latter, Charlie identifies and articulates common sounds and vocal utterances in their musical note equivalents: a character cackles a crazy frozen laugh that measures from middle C to F-sharp
and he hears a wail or howl . . . in the G above middle C.
Charlie’s motives for making the trip are selfish rather than altruistic. Not only does he do it to spite
his dying brother (after a violent altercation over a disputed love-interest), he also sees it as a way of provinghe can survive the hardship. Thus, fundraising concerns are peripheral, and Larry is assigned the role of antagonist, providing Charlie with the negative, fist-shaking impetus to keep moving. And though their relationship is often caricatured, Charlie’s journey and his freely chosen confrontation with mortality sits uneasily with his brother’s forced confrontation with the same. Thus, the reader’s sympathy for Charlie’s self-imposed middle-class plight wavers throughout. But maybe this is precisely Sedore’s point: both men are equally cold in their own way. They are the titular snowmen, and their coldness exists between them rather than in one or the other. In this sense, Sedore’s novel is more an exploration of contemporary masculinity and the gender expectations that sometimes stifle the bonds between men—even brothers.
Tom Managhan’s The Bottle Collector is an episodic novel depicting the solo sailing trip of Mark Weathers, from Windsor to Thunder Bay. As a retired psychologist steeped in middle-aged reflection, Mark is unhappy that his life has failed to measure up to his past ideals. Thus, he decides that if he doesn’t find a reason to keep living at the end of his journey, he will commit suicide. The novel vacillates between sweeping existential meditation and everyday observation, the latter eventually leading Mark to appreciate the simple goals and achievements in life, such as the search for bottles undertaken by two peripheral characters in the novel. Managhan’s humour, as channelled through Mark, is sarcastic and occasionally condescending, symptomatic of the protagonist’s self-loathing as projected onto others. And though Managhan depicts Mark as wavering between offensive defensiveness and apologetic self-reproach, his character is often difficult to sympathize with. Particularly problematic are Managhan’s representations of rural characters through Mark’s point-of-view: most are unflattering rural stereotypes, from boisterous and uncultivated to simple and docile country folk. This representation is sometimes subtle, other times humorously foregrounded—but either way, the condescension is there. This criticism aside, Managhan’s novel is at times both funny and insightful, as Mark learns to appreciate the link between the collection of discarded bottles for redemption as a redemptive process in itself, and his own previous occupation as a psychologist who tried to redeem those left behind by a society with loftier goals in mind.
Similar reviews
- Studying Canadian Studies by Kit Dobson
Books reviewed: Canadian Cultural Studies: A Reader by Gail Faurschou, Sourayan Mookerjea, and Imre Szeman - Awash in Linguistic (and Intestinal) Doubt by Christine Stewart
Books reviewed: Expeditions of a Chimæra by Oana Avasilichioaei and Erín Moure and The Exile Book of Poetry in Translation: 20 Canadian Poets Take on the World by Priscila Uppal - This City is Made for Walking by Maia Joseph
Books reviewed: The Walkable City: Fraus Haussmann's Boulevards to Jane Jacobs' Streets and Beyond by Mary Soderstrom - Canadian Gardening by Gisela Hönnighausen
Books reviewed: A History of Canadian Gardening by Carol Martin and Gardens of Vancouver by Christine Allen and Collin Varner - Disaplacements by Sherry Simon
Books reviewed: Making a Difference : Canadian Multicultural Literature by Smaro Kamboureli
MLA: Shaw, Justin. Death and Transcendence. canlit.ca. Canadian Literature, 14 Aug. 2012. Web. 25 May 2013.
***Please note that the articles and reviews from the Canadian Literature website (www.canlit.ca) may not be the final versions as they are printed in the journal, as additional editing sometimes takes place between the two versions. If you are quoting from the website, please indicate the date accessed when citing the web version of reviews and articles.
