Enduring Colonialism in Canadian News
- Mark Cronlund Anderson (Author) and Carmen L. Robertson (Author)
Seeing Red: A History of Natives in Canadian Newspapers. University of Manitoba Press (purchase at Amazon.ca)
Reviewed by Candis Callison
No one would want to look in a mirror to see a reflection that is unflattering, ghastly even, and inconsistent with one’s own sense of self. Yet, Seeing Red by Mark Cronlund Anderson and Carmen L. Robertson produce such a mirror. While many Canadians are likely to perceive their newspapers as reflective of long cherished values of racial tolerance and multiculturalism, Anderson and Robertson find disturbing, persistent, and enduring colonial stereotypes in Canadian newspapers.
Seeing Red is a wonderfully dense and rich historical work that situates itself equally amongst journalism history, colonial histories in the Americas, and scholarship on representations of minorities and race in Canadian media. It begins with the sale of Rupert’s Land in 1869, and in the following eleven chapters, methodically walks through other major historical moments in Canada: the signing of Treaty 3 in 1873, Louis Riel’s death and the North-West Rebellion in 1885, the Klondike Gold Rush in 1898, the death of Mohawk poet Pauline Johnson in 1913, the unmasking of Grey Owl (Archie Belaney) in 1938, post-World War II coverage of Aboriginal people in 1948, the White Paper in 1969, the Anicinabe Park Standoff in 1974, the passing of Bill C-31 in 1985, Oka in 1990, and the Prairie Centennial in 2005. The conclusion ends with a scathing critique of Margaret Wente’s long running column in the Globe and Mail. The authors argue that Wente’s
common sense approach reflects many of the same—now naturalized—colonial predilections for binary comparison where Aboriginal people are always found wanting morally, physically, mentally, historically.
Anderson is a historian, primarily of Latin America and American film; Robertson an art historian and curator with Lakota and Scottish roots. They view the press as agenda-setters who not only frame issues for an
imagined community, but also provide the public with
ready-made consumable opinions. Gramsci’s idea of hegemonic ordering provides a key theoretical framework for understanding what lies behind the
othering process, where inequality is consistently used in various ways to
promote a nation.
Methodologically, Anderson and Robertson approach historical news coverage slightly differently in each chapter. This should not be seen as a deficiency, but rather as a way of investigating both national and regional journalism in ways that reveal the durability and malleability of stereotypes. For example, the first several chapters look at coverage from the Toronto Globe and the Montreal Gazette, while the Klondike chapter focuses on five newly established Yukon newspapers. As Canada and its reporting capabilities expand, Anderson and Robertson enlarge their terrain to, for example, looking at the coverage of the White Paper in 1969 in eighteen regional and national dailies.
The book covers a vast historical landscape in terms of the development of journalism, beginning in the partisan (and often yellow) period through to the more professionalized objective version of the early twenty-first century. That this shift hasn’t eradicated deeply held colonial attitudes towards Aboriginal people is a critique that remains prescient, and could be applied as well to recent coverage of the crisis in Attawapiskat.
- Tons de blanc by Thierry Bissonnette
Books reviewed: Le bruissement des possibles by Antoine Boisclair
- Six Kings and a Pawn by Ted Binnema
Books reviewed: Letters From Rupert's Land, 1826-1840 by Helen E. Ross and Merchant Kings: When Companies Ruled the World, 1600-1900 by Stephen R. Bown
- In Search of the Sacred by David Kent
Books reviewed: A Concise History of Christianity in Canada by Terence Murphy and Roberto Perin and Locations of the Sacred: Essays on Religion, Literature, and Canadian Culture by William C. James
- Women Writing Celebrity by Faye Hammill
Books reviewed: Women, Celebrity, and Literary Culture Between the Wars by Faye Hammill
- The Afterlife of Trauma by Marlene Briggs
Books reviewed: Traumatic Realism: The Demands of Holocaust Representations by Michael Rothberg, Echoes of Combat: Trauma, Memory, and the Vietnam War by Fred Turner, and The Limits of Autobiography: Trauma and Testimony by Leigh Gilmore
MLA: Callison, Candis. Enduring Colonialism in Canadian News. canlit.ca. Canadian Literature, 17 Apr. 2012. Web. 5 Dec. 2013.
This review originally appeared in Canadian Literature #215 (Winter 2012), Indigenous Focus. (pg. 140 - 140)
***Please note that the articles and reviews from the Canadian Literature website (www.canlit.ca) may not be the final versions as they are printed in the journal, as additional editing sometimes takes place between the two versions. If you are quoting from the website, please indicate the date accessed when citing the web version of reviews and articles.