Book Review
More than a Patchwork
- Carol Shields (Editor) and Margjorie Anderson (Editor)
Dropped Threads 2: More of What We Aren't Told. Vintage (purchase at Amazon.ca)
Reviewed by Judith Plessis
When I attended a reading of the original Dropped Threads in Vancouver, I was directed to the overflow room of a modest church in Kitsilano as the main congregation hall was packed. This “standing room only” reception represented the enthusiasm felt all over the country about women’s storytelling. We were eager to hear secret narratives—stories we hadn’t been told! After the success of the first collection published in 2001, many Canadian women wanted to tell their stories, and the editors made it possible by inviting submissions for Dropped Threads 2.
But one does not have to have read the original Dropped Threads to enjoy the sequel. Dropped Threads 2 has used the idea of reader participation to produce an even broader and more inclusive anthology than the first. The new collection draws on the insights of women from many walks of life and depicts more multicultural and diverse experiences than the original collection. The second generation of Dropped Threads contributors could look to the first stories, gain confidence in writing about experi- ences they hadn’t previously felt comfortable sharing, and fill in what was missing from the original collection.
Dropped Threads 2 is slightly longer than the original, with an organised table of contents divided into four chapters: “End Notes,” “Variations,” “Glimpses,” and “Nourishment.” Each of these categories is a loose grouping of about nine stories, on a similar theme. The insights come from the experiences of each author, but many of the stories have strong political overtones. “End Notes” deals with feminist topics such as rape, brutality against women, child abuse, and attempted suicide. “Variations” focuses on several challenges for women, including widowhood, psychiatric illness, breast cancer, and single motherhood. “Glimpses” shares musings and private thoughts that have shaped the authors as adult women writers. “Nourishment,” as its title indicates, explores motherhood and the friendships between women here in North America as well as in third world countries. The final story in the last chapter, “Speaking of Dying” by Shelagh Rogers, is a poignant tribute to its subject, Kate Carmichael, and posthumously to Carol Shields herself.
The writing by all the contributors in Dropped Threads 2 is honest and eloquent. The book includes several well-known Canadian authors such as Jane Urquhart, Sandra Martin, and Michele Landsberg. It is hard to forget the horrific description of child rape and the victim’s emotions in Pamela Mala Sinha’s “Hiding” or the anguish of being unable to conceive a child, in Lisa Majeau Gordon’s “An Exercise in Fertility.”
There is also humour in this anthology. For In “Ten Beauty Tips You Never Asked For,” Elizabeth Hay discusses skin creams and lotions before lamenting that nothing really works to stop the process of decay. In C.J. Papoutsis’ “They Didn’t Come With Instructions,” the author’s self-deprecating wit nudges us to think of examples of our own trials in child raising.
In her thoughtful foreword, Adrienne Clarkson explains the power of these individual “vignettes”: “Perhaps that is what women’s lives are really like—snowflakes with infinitely different patterns, complete in themselves.” I did not discover these “snowflakes,” however, by reading the collection chronologically. I explored essays from one chapter and then moved on to another section, often returning to reread a story with a new awareness a second or third time. Readers of Dropped Threads 2 will be amazed to partake in such illuminating conversations with complete strangers.
Similar reviews
- Fictions de Québecoises by Louise H. Forsyth
Books reviewed: Le roman québécois au féminin (1980-1995) by Gabrielle Pascal - Truth and Convention by Lawrence Mathews
Books reviewed: Winter's Descent by Don Gutteridge, Everything but the Truth by Christopher McPherson, and dad says he saw you at the mall by Ken Sparling - (Re)Construction Zones by Maria Truchan-Tataryn
Books reviewed: Ephemeral Territories by Erin Manning and Literary Culture and Female Authorship in Canada 1760-2000 by Faye Hammill - Sit, Stay, and Play by Owen Percy
Books reviewed: The Exile Book of Canadian Dog Stories by Richard Teleky and The Exile Book of Canadian Sports Stories by Priscilla Uppal - Challenging Poverty by Laurie Aikman
Books reviewed: Out of Poverty and into Something More Comfortable by John Stackhouse and Remnants of Nation: On Poverty Narratives by Women by Roxanne L. Rimstead
MLA: Plessis, Judith. More than a Patchwork. canlit.ca. Canadian Literature, 8 Dec. 2011. Web. 23 May 2013.
This review originally appeared in Canadian Literature #185 (Summer 2005), (Stratton, Compton, Morra, Wylie, Gordon). (pg. 180 - 181)
***Please note that the articles and reviews from the Canadian Literature website (www.canlit.ca) may not be the final versions as they are printed in the journal, as additional editing sometimes takes place between the two versions. If you are quoting from the website, please indicate the date accessed when citing the web version of reviews and articles.
