When Amelia DeFalco published Imagining Care: Responsibility, Dependency, and Canadian Literature in 2016, what many call the Care Turn was well underway across the humanities and health sciences. The realities and impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic further fuelled the turn’s transversal scope, bringing new circumstances and inequities to light. Shane Neilson’s book Canadian Literature and Medicine: Carelanding, suggests that this critical interest in caring structures and relations has not lost momentum and keeps providing new avenues for interrogating and circumscribing the role of care in cultural, political, and medical life in Canada. Neilson, a literary scholar and physician, is well-equipped to examine how “the imaginative representations of the plight and fact of care in Canada informed the development of the socialized system” (12). He asks how relying on literary productions can help better understand the limits of biomedicine and foster, through the comparative and contrasting analysis of Western and Indigenous epistemologies more particularly, “conditions in which a different kind of care can flow” (35).
To better understand the “evolution of the Canadian health-care system, one that has its basis in care” (43), Neilson seeks to reactualize the literary trope of the garrison mentality—coined by Northrop Frye—instead of relying on the often-dominant toolkit of narrative medicine developed by Rita Charon in the United States. Aware of the limitations of Frye’s metaphor and Charon’s concept, Neilson reframes the former with feminist care ethics and what he calls “Indigenous story medicine” to show how the latter “is a bit-player” compared to this tripartite critical apparatus (48). Accordingly, across three chapters, the first section titled “Theoretical Entanglements”, articulates how the author critically brings each concept into play and aligns them with his “socially constructivistic reading of the medical garrison mentality in Canadian life” (41). Neilson is careful not to simplistically apply a care ethics analysis grid to his corpus or to extract convenient notions and knowledge from the Indigenous epistemologies and theories he mobilizes. Instead, he makes space for a framework that amplifies the scope of care ethics and politics by turning to Julia Kristeva’s work on translation and the “nature-culture divide,” as well as Luce Irigaray’s healthy suspicion towards the association of care and women through a naturalized relationality that risks perpetuating patriarchal structures. The last part of this critical section opens “an ethical space of engagement” to argue for redesigning a “narrative competence” informed by relational forms of knowing (56, 62). To do so, Neilson reminds us of the epistemic genealogy of the colonial project, accomplished through land theft and the “de-storying” of ways of knowing, contrasting this heritage with Indigenous story medicine and further stressing how, by implementing such a shift towards relationality, “Western medicine might humbly renovate itself” (65).
This shift unfolds in section 2, “Indigenous Care and Narrative Medicine,” which is divided into two chapters. Chapter 4, “The Origin Story of Care on the Land is Indigenous,” examines accounts of care relations in texts by Jacques Cartier, Samuel de Champlain, and Marc Lescarbot to situate the origins of ongoing systemic racism in health care today. This chapter studies how, despite the overt racism and violence against Indigenous people, “care survives in genocidal accounts not otherwise congenial to the cultivation of care” (71). Cautious not to romanticize and lucid with regards to Eurocentric biases in reading, Neilson suggests that “cooperation and harmonious relations with Indigenous Peoples resulted in greater health for early settler populations, and at great cost to Indigenous ones” (90). Chapter 5 “interrogate[s] the Eurocentric episteme-driven practice of generalizability that is, by design, destructive to individual specificity” and deconstructs further the ways “the colonizers attempt to Europeanize all knowledge and heritage, even when they are extending beyond their knowledge into the unknown” (96). Neilson thickens narrative medicine with Indigenous conceptualizations and narrative practices by making a case for a situated, contextualized, and relational approach to narrative to better attend to pain and its experience. Drawing on artists and thinkers whose work probes “the use and function of story in terms of health” (110), such as Leanne Betasamosake Simpson, Jo-Ann Episkenew, and Richard Wagamese, Neilson’s complex critical discussion provides a rich and multilayered exploration of care-related tensions in the development of the settler state and Western biomedical epistemology, stressing again care’s fundamental meaning for Indigenous cosmologies. This section is organized “in a sequence that deliberately precedes the story of the development of the socialized health-care system because that system could not be known, nor could it be respectfully presented, without reckoning with its coloniality” (121), and provides rigorous and valuable knowledge for many scholars and practitioners of care and health across disciplines.
Section 3 dives into “Co-constructions of Canadian Literature and Medicine” with another set of two chapters. Chapter 6, “Garrison and Hospital,” looks at late-nineteenth-century fiction, non-fiction, and policy documents in terms of a feminist ethics of care, as well as through a medical lens. In addition to amplifying scholarship on care ethics and poetics by looking at early literary texts beyond fiction, this chapter shows quite convincingly the development and impacts of care not only as relational but as a commodity and source of financial strain, further stressing the importance of considering care, especially with regards to medicine, holistically and beyond abstract policy-making. Moving forward in time, chapter 7 addresses mid-twentieth-century “prairie realism” by drawing a parallel between “Canadian fiction being less enamoured of romance” and the development of “provincial and national legislation mandating socialized care” (167). Neilson does so first through the literary analysis of para-ordinary or non-professional care in two prairie novels from the 1920s, Settlers of the Marsh and Wild Geese, then by revisiting Bonheur d’occasion (The Tin Flute) and poems by F. R. Scott and Dorothy Livesay. This chapter is particularly useful in connecting literary productions to policy-making and legislative changes. It is also thought-provoking in its argument that “in the entanglement of literature and medicine, a primary shaping value is neither ethics nor political economy but aesthetics” (189).
The book ends with a section on biomedical neoliberalism in contemporary times, a period during “which a health system, initially created partly out of fear, began to be dismantled in a process that has accelerated to the present” (205). In chapter 8, the author brings the medical profession into focus, robustly weaving together the critical threads of the “neoliberalization of the socialized system, burnout, internalization, and compensation for the system’s inadequacies” to provide a textured, historicized, and interdisciplinary mapping of the ways discourses on resilience and adaptability found in literary texts respond to national economies and politics of care in the medical system (216). Chapter 9 then interrogates the neoliberalization of public health through the context of the COVID-19 pandemic by looking at Saleema Nawaz’s novel Songs for the End of the World, stressing how this global event highlighted a particular “Canadian cultural imperative to care, though that imperative is inequitably felt across many lines of Canadian society” (18).
Written in an engaging, at times informal yet refined language that makes space for a few well-located autobiographical comments, Canadian Literature and Medicine: Carelanding has the potential to open up meaningful, much-needed conversations about the mythologized notion of socialized health care in Canada. Neilson also makes a strong case for resituating biomedicine within a more extensive ethics of care, the latter of which must also be held accountable and relate not only to public health policies and scholarship from the Western humanities but also to Indigenous story medicine and relationality.
Canadian Literature is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.